The FHA’s tiered system for assessing servicers’ use of loss mitigation tools should serve more as a red flag for increased supervision rather than as a basis for terminating servicing rights, said the Mortgage Bankers Association. Commenting on the FHA’s proposed enhancements to its servicer scorecard, the MBA acknowledged the agency’s responsibility to monitor and hold servicers accountable for poor performance. But while tiered ranking is a good enforcement tool, it can be misapplied, the group indicated. Any ranking system is a good first ...

FHA endorsements saw very little improvement in May as mortgage interest rates began to climb, according to Inside FHA Lending’s analysis of FHA data. Total FHA originations rose only 2.4 percent in May to $22.0 billion from $21.5 billion the previous month, and 8.9 percent on a year-over-year basis. Volume was split down the middle between purchase and refinancings, with rates rising from 3.35 percent during the first week of May to 3.81 percent at the end of May. Retail accounted for 81 percent of FHA endorsements, which were mostly 30-year, fixed-rate mortgages. The average interest rate for FHA-insured, 30-year FRMs was ... [1 chart]

Reverse mortgage lenders, consumer groups and certain advocates for the elderly are urging Congress to enact legislation passed recently by the House of Representatives granting the FHA additional authority to govern its reverse mortgage program. Testifying before the Senate Banking Subcommittee on Housing, Transportation and Community Development, the groups said the most productive action Congress can take is to pass H.R. 2167 to allow HUD to make expeditious changes to the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage program through mortgagee letters. The bill, which the House approved on June 12, would ...

Deep-freezing the Home Equity Conversion Mortgage program’s full-draw, fixed-rate standard product apparently has not diminished borrowers’ appetite for reverse mortgages as indicated by a significant increase in HECM originations in the first quarter of 2013. FHA endorsements under the HECM program surged 36.2 percent during the first three months of 2013, with lenders reporting $3.84 billion at the end of the quarter, according to Inside FHA Lending’s analysis of FHA data. Volume was also up a modest 5.3 percent from the same period a year ago. The Department of Housing and Urban Development announced the ... [1 chart]

Lenders that originate home loans to hold in portfolio are concerned about the regulatory consequences of originating non-qualified mortgages. While some have asked for a blanket exemption from liability for non-QMs held in portfolio, Democrats in Congress appear unlikely to approve such changes. “Congress should amend the ability-to-repay statute to grant QM status to all mortgage loans held in portfolio by community banks,” Charles Vice, commissioner of the Kentucky Department of ...

Bank and thrift holdings of home-equity loans continue to decline, according to the Inside Mortgage Finance Bank Mortgage Database. Performance on the loans has been mixed, and there are concerns about the expiring interest-only period on vintage home-equity lines of credit. Banks and thrifts held $1.07 trillion in HELs – HELOCs, unused HELOC commitments and closed-end second liens – at the end of the first quarter of 2013, down 1.8 percent from the previous quarter. TD Bank was ... [Includes one data chart]

The five servicers involved in the $25 billion national servicing settlement have largely complied with the 304 standards included in the settlement. However, Bank of America, CitiMortgage, JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo each failed at least one metric tested in the settlement and could face monetary penalties. In a report released last week, Joseph Smith, the settlement’s monitor, said he found eight failed metrics: two by BofA, three by Citi, two by Chase and one by Wells Fargo. Only the ...

For the past two years, Bank of America has been the poster child of legacy servicing sales, but it may soon have some company. According to industry advisors who specialize in the mortgage servicing rights market, JPMorgan Chase and a few other large banks with seasoned portfolios are developing “deal teams” to explore their options. Chase’s name has surfaced from time to time as a select seller of legacy product. But it also has been a selective buyer of servicing, including the purchase last fall of $70 billion in rights from MetLife, which was closing out its interest in the mortgage business. A spokeswoman for Chase declined...

It’s no secret that speculators wide and far are betting the common and preferred shares of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac could rise significantly as their profits continue to stay robust. But according to James Lockhart, who once headed the Federal Housing Finance Agency, these speculators are likely throwing their money away. Speaking at a recent housing forum sponsored by the Bipartisan Policy Center, he noted that the Treasury Department owns the senior preferred of the GSEs and the senior stock “sits above” the junior shares. Lockhart said the government preferred will never be paid back, which means the junior holders are out of luck. Lockhart, who now serves as vice chairman of WL Ross & Co., said he does not own any stock in the two nor does he plan on buying any.

With just a week to go, the petition drive by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac common shareholders asking the White House to “restore fairness” to the value of their lost investment looks like it will fall woefully short of the required number of signatures. Created on June 1, the petition posted on the White House website calls for Congress, the Treasury Department and the Federal Housing Finance Agency to enact a method “to provide fairness and protection” to common shareholders of the two GSEs “and enable shareholders to have participation in the recovery value of their stock.”